Ritual hand washing



Meet Our Team


Reverend Lisa Day


Favorite Bible verse: Isaiah 43:1-2

Do not fear, for I have redeemed you; I have called you by name, you are mine. When you pass through the waters, I will be with you; and through the rivers, they shall not overwhelm you; when you walk through fire you shall not be burned, and the flame shall not consume you.

Lisa began serving with us in October 2014. She is a second career pastor, having worked for twenty years as a public interest lawyer, serving low income clients and persons with disabilities in Los Angeles and Philadelphia. She was ordained as a Presbyterian Elder in her early 20s in Los Angeles, and just over 20 years later was ordained as a teaching elder (minister of Word and Sacrament). Lisa served for 7 1/2 years as Associate Pastor for Congregational Care and Older Adult Ministries at Swarthmore Presbyterian Church before being called to serve at First Presbyterian Church of Hightstown. Lisa has lived in Mercer County since moving to New Jersey in 1990, living in Ewing and Lawrenceville before moving to Hightstown.

Lisa graduated from Occidental College in Los Angeles, and received her J.D. from UCLA School of Law. In 2007, she received her MDiv from Princeton Theological Seminary. She grew up on Guam, daughter to a Navy pilot father and middle school guidance counselor mother. She is the proud single mother to three adult children, Elizabeth, Hannah and Joseph Donoghue. Lisa loves word games, board games, richly drawn television dramas, independent films and the Phillies.

Lisa says, “In me, you will find a pastor with a passion for fostering inter-generational relationships through shared learning, worship and fellowship; who appreciates the gifts, perspectives and good company of folks of all ages, abilities and cultures; who has a heart for social justice and ministry and for discovering what God is already up to in the neighborhood; who is unafraid to walk with those in the parts of our faith journey marked by lament and doubt; and who is open to discovering and nurturing the God-given gifts of all people.”

Reverend Lisa Day

Reverend Lisa Day



Princeton Theological Seminary, M.Div. 2007

UCLA School of Law, J.D. 1986

Occidental College, A.B. English, Magna Cum Laude, 1983, Phi Beta Kappa, Mortar Board


Work Experience

Lisa worked 20 years as an attorney representing low income clients and persons with disabilities in Los Angeles and Philadelphia.

“I loved my vocation as advocate, but felt my heart singing in my work in the church.”



Mary Maleski is our Director of Children and Youth Ministries and has been a member of our church staff since August 2005.  Prior to joining us, Mary's experience included teaching preschool at Play & Learn, and working as the Christian educator for The First Presbyterian Church of Bordentown.  She graduated from The College of New Jersey with a degree in Early Childhood/Elementary Ed.  In 2005, upon the completion of her coursework/exams at the Princeton Theological Seminary, she celebrated her new title - Certified Christian Educator.  Certified Christian Educator is the highest level of certification recognized in the PC(USA) for Christian educators.

Sheri Devlin is our Office Manager.  She has been a member of the church since 2001, has taught Sunday school for 15 years and is the Kids Club Coordinator.  Sheri was previously employed by Princeton University at Firestone Library for 10 years before taking time off to raise her children.  Since then, she has been helping out in the office as needed.  She is a Hightstown native, with strong ties to this community.  Sheri lives in Hightstown with her husband, 5 children, 2 dogs and 2 cats.

Connor Fluharty, Music Director

Debbie Tarby  is our Music Director. She comes to us with deep faith, great skills and a big heart. She has over 25 years’ experience as a church music director, directing and founding a number of vocal and bell choirs, playing the organ, and leading music programs of various sizes, ages and skill levels. She also brings the gifts of an experienced music educator.

Debbie extends this invitation, welcoming “congregants of all ages to sing and play instruments. I assure you that participation in church music will draw you closer to God and church life.”

Julia Henry  is our new Kids Music Director.

“My name is Julia Henry and I'll be the new children and youth music director this upcoming year. I'm originally from Richmond, Virginia and a recent graduate of Westminster Choir College. Yay!!! I'm truly a child at heart with a love for making and sharing music! Can't wait for the amazing year that awaits us!”

©2018 First Presbyterian Church of Hightstown, All rights reserved. 609-448-0055